Relative Energy Deficiency in Sports (RED-S) Syndrome – What Runners Need to Know

  Jun 11, 2020  |  #Running

Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport Syndrome, simply known as RED-S, is a comprehensive term that includes education and an explanation of symptoms of underfueling and energy deficiency among athletes, both male and female.

Collage of female athletes for RED-S | Bucket List Tummy

As an Amazon Affiliate, I may earn from qualifying purchases.

It is important for runners to pay attention to their nutrition intake, and when I say that, I mainly mean eating enough.

However, sometimes what starts out as paying attention to nutrition quickly spirals into increased restriction, food rules, disordered eating behaviors, and even full-blown eating disorders.

A hyperfocus on health quickly leads us down a different path. 

Relative Energy Deficiency in Sports (RED-S) Syndrome can happen when a runner or athlete is not fueling his or her body adequately with enough nutrition and calories to support the demands of his or her sport. As I’ll discuss, it can come across from intentional undereating (food rules and diet culture), or unintentionally. 

What is RED-S?

RED-S Syndrome is a broader, more comprehensive term for what was previously known as the Female Athlete Triad. The Female Athlete Triad formally referred to a situation in which females experienced a deficiency in dietary intake via disordered eating behaviors or unintentional underfueling.

female runner stretching and eating apple

This underfueling results in a loss of the menstrual cycle (known as amenorrhea) and low bone mineral density.

The change from the Female Athlete Triad to RED-S was made primarily to include a more robust and description of symptoms caused by energy deficiency.

The new diagnosis also includes males, as they are not immune from the effects of energy deficiency and its symptoms.

What Does Relative Energy Deficiency Mean?

Relative energy deficiency (in sport) refers to when an athlete or active individual is not consuming enough nutrition or calories for the body to function adequately in all realms. This includes and affects metabolism, menstrual cycle, bone health, and more.

The deficiency in energy may be intentional (such as when someone is trying to lose weight by restricting intake) or it may be unintentional (such as when someone fails to increase their food intake to match an increase in exercise or training).

RED-S affects many aspects of health including:

  • physiological
  • emotional
  • mental
  • relational
  • overall health

It also has a devastating impact on athletic performance.

It is important to note that RED-S can occur in individuals of varying body shapes and sizes. There is no “one size fits all” when it comes to energy deficiency, disordered eating, and adverse effects of not consuming adequate nutrition.

Even recreational runners and exercisers are at risk for energy deficiency and RED-S.

Why Does A Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport Occur?

This relative energy deficiency in sport occurs because there is an imbalance between energy intake and energy output.

black woman lifting weights

When we do not receive enough nutrition or overall calories, our bodies begin to compensate by slowing down metabolism, altering hormones (which can alter or cease the menstrual cycle in females, among other things), and other physiological adaptations.

Again, this may be intentional or unintentional. Inadequate energy intake may be intentional due to an individual’s attempts at weight loss or body composition changes (either through dieting or exercise or both). Or even an attempt to follow the so-called Wellness Diet

It may also be intentional due to societal pressure to look a certain way, whether for a sport or trying to achieve an unrealistic expectation of body shape and size.

black running shoes with road ahead | Bucket List Tummy

On the other hand, inadequate energy intake may be unintentional due to an individual not matching their intake with their output. This can happen to individuals new to exercise and training that don’t realize they aren’t consuming enough to support their new exercise habits.

Unintentional underfueling may also happen as a result of an athlete or active individual not prioritizing their nutrition plan, not making time to eat consistency and include snacks around workouts, or even forgetting to refuel their bodies throughout the day.

Ultimately, RED-S occurs when an individual is not consuming enough calories and nutrition to adequately sustain the body for everyday energy expenditure, on top of the additional energy output via movement and exercise.

Simply put, there is an imbalance between energy in and energy out.

Energy input is not equal to energy output | www.bucketlittummy.com

Warning Signs and Consequences of Chronic Energy Deficiency

There are many factors to consider when it comes to RED-S and chronic energy deficiency.

Previously, being known as the Female Athlete Triad, the main warning signs were loss of menstrual cycle (amenorrhea) in females, low body weight and/or body fat, and a loss of bone mineral density, which could result in stress fractures or bone breaks.

Now, RED-S is known to cause even more problems than what the Triad included. It now extends to psychological disturbances, such as obsessing about food and exercise, mood swings, and irritability.

bed white white sheets and white pillowcase

RED-S may also interfere with an individual’s ability to sleep, which impacts overall energy levels, hormones, and moods. Furthermore, being in an energy deficit may also interfere with an individual’s ability to recover from exercise.

This can also lead to chronic fatigue, overuse injuries, and an increased risk for infections and illness. 

This post talks more about overexercise and compulsive exercise

The following image from the IOC Consensus Statement: Beyond the Female Athlete Triad—Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S), shows the many ways RED-S can impact the body.

a visual representation of how RED-S can affect many systems within an athelete

How Being In An Energy Deficiency Can Impact Your Physical Performance

Inadequate energy intake resulting in RED-S also has an impact on an athlete or active individual’s physical performance. You can imagine this to be true, considering all of the body functions and systems that are affected.

Athletes in an energy deficiency may experience:

  • frequent illness (such as the common cold or upper respiratory infections).
  • decreased training responses and adaptations
  • decreased performance
  • more fatigue and less energy
  • decreased muscle strength
  • decreased concentration and coordination
  • irritability
  • decreased glycogen stores
  • increased injury risk (especially muscle and bone pain and injuries)

All of these consequences can result in decreased strength, endurance, and power leading to worsening athletic performance.

The following image from the IOC Consensus Statement: Beyond the Female Athlete Triad—Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S), shows the many ways RED-S can impact your physical performance.

a visual representation of how RED-S can affects physical performance in athletes from the IOC

So ultimately, what may have started out as a seemingly innocent attempt at “getting healthy” or to lose weight or body fat, if taken too far, can result in severe consequences for one’s health and athletic performance.

It is important to not ignore the warning signs and to seek treatment as soon as possible. This can help avoid the long-term effects RED-S can have on the body.

What Does Treatment for RED-S Look Like?

Seeking treatment for RED-S is essential, regardless of body shape or size, the severity of symptoms, or the level at which you engage in your sport or exercise.

checklist on chalkboard | Bucket List Tummy

Don’t Ignore The Warning Signs – In the past, it has been common practice to ignore the warning sign of a female athlete not obtaining their menstrual cycle. Having inconsistent menstrual cycles or the complete loss of menstrual cycles at times during training has also been ignored.

This used to be thought of as a “normal” result of being an athlete or of competing at a high level. But it is truly a sign that the body is undernourished (or another underlying medical condition), and can lead to serious health consequences.

Check Labs (Hormones, Bone Density) – Getting testing done to check hormone levels, bone density levels and other health measures is important. It will likely give you a fuller and clearer picture of what’s going on in the body than just focusing on body weight.

Look Beyond Body Weight – RED-S and its consequences can occur even if someone is not considered to be at a low body weight for their age and height. It can also occur in an individual whose body weight has not changed.

Utilize a Team of Health Professionals – Treatment for RED-S may include a team of health professionals such as a General Practitioner (GP), Registered Dietitian (RD), psychologist, and more. Much will depend on how long the issue has been occurring and how ready and willing one is to seek and receive treatment.

Overall, treatment for RED-S will include getting the body to a more appropriate energy balance. This may be through an increase in nutrition intake, a decrease in training, or both.

Depending on the individual’s symptoms and willingness to participate in treatment strategies, this may occur slowly. Adding in approximately 200-300 calories or more per day via food or nutritional supplements, decreasing physical activity and training intensity and duration, or both, is one strategy. 

group of people enjoying a meal together

If an individual is ready to go “all in” with treatment, restoring the body to energy balance may occur more quickly. One such was to do so is adding in approximately 500 or more calories per day and/or decreasing physical activity and training by a more significant amount.

This is where a treatment team comes into play to help the individual navigate the nutrition requirements and changes. Additionally, a treatment team can moniter mental and psychological effects of these changes, as well as the health status of the individual.

The time it takes for someone to achieve energy balance and resume more normal bodily functions, such as obtaining a menstrual cycle for females, varies greatly.

It is important to continue treatment and stay the course until you are in a more stable energy balance. This may result in a change in body weight, although it may not, which can be hard for some individuals to handle and that’s why it’s important to have an RD and a psychologist on your treatment team.

What About Birth Control Pills for Regaining the Menstrual Cycle?

I get this question often and I think it’s important to explain why this approach does not approach the root cause or symptoms. 

birth control pills

Although birth control pills are often prescribed when a female athlete is not obtaining her menstrual cycle naturally, it is not a recommended course of treatment. Instead of addressing the root cause of the problem, birth control pills are simply masking the symptoms. This can lead an individual to think they are better, which is not the case.

While once thought that birth control pills may prevent some of the bone loss associated with RED-S, studies have shown that to be inaccurate.

Recent studies have shown that women who received oral contraceptives but did not gain weight, continued to lose bone mineral density. Additionally, women who received oral contraceptives and gained a small amount of weight also showed no improvement to their bone mineral density.

Women who did not receive oral contraceptives but increased their weight and resumed their menstrual cycle naturally saw an increase in bone mineral density.

Restoring your body to adequate energy intake and regaining your menstrual cycle naturally is the best course of treatment. However, it takes time, patience and some discomfort. 

Additional Reading/Resources:

RED-S really came to light in the media when some former collegiate and professional athletes shared their stories. Experiences ranging from overtraining, being underweight, pressure from coaches and peers to look a certain way, and the consequences that resulted spread wide. 

  • Elite runner Mary Cain shared her story that her coaching program was emotionally and physically abusive and led to devastating injuries and derailed her career.
  • Former professional runner, Lauren Fleshman, wrote a letter to her younger self about what she wished she would’ve known and done differently. This is a truly powerful article for young athletes to read.

 

 

This article was researched and written by Jill Merkel, MS, RD, CSSD, Owner of Jill Merkel RD Coaching & Consulting, and edited by Sarah Schlicher, MPH, RDN.

What other questions do you have about RED-S?

 

Sources:

Bergstrom, Ingrid, et al. Women with anorexia nervosa should not be treated with estrogen or birth control pills in a bone‐sparing effectObstetrics & Gynaecology. (2013). 92:8 (877-880).

Mountjoy MSundgot-Borgen JBurke L, et al. The IOC consensus statement: beyond the Female Athlete Triad—Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S).
 

Nazem, Taraneh Gharib, and Kathryn E Ackerman. The Female Athlete Triad. Sports Health. (2012): 4,4: 302-11. 

4 responses to “Relative Energy Deficiency in Sports (RED-S) Syndrome – What Runners Need to Know

    1. That’s a great question! Yes, you can. Your body can still experience other symptoms (ie mood/depression/bone or stress fractures, and more) even if you have a natural period.

  1. I think this is a great post! RED-S seems to be a hot topic recently after Mary Cain came out a few months ago (a year ago maybe?). That’s interesting about birth control though.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

shares