Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

  Aug 21, 2016  |  #Recipes

This Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich is a nutrient-packed sandwich that doesn’t sacrifice any flavor! It can be made in under 15 minutes and boasts a nice balance of sweet and savory!

Hello! I’m thrilled to share an epic veggie sandwich with you today.

So, little life update: I recently joined the Recipe Redux challenge, which is founded by Registered Dietitians. It focuses on making delicious dishes healthier. There are monthly prompts, and the challenge is to create a better-for-you recipe within the monthly prompt. How fitting that this month’s prompt is a Vacation-Inspired Recipe.


As a result of completely indulging in the foodie city of Vancouver, I was not short of ideas. You can read my first recap here, and I’ll have part two coming this week! However, most of my ideas revolved around fresh fish and produce. Ultimately, though, I decided on this epic veggie sandwich because I love sandwiches, and I feared my fresh fish here wouldn’t compare to the pacific coast fresh fish we consumed in British Columbia.

When I posted this on Instagram and got so many responses and even private messages about it, I knew I had to take action and create it myself.

Veggie Sandwich
The original Veggie Sandwich from Tap Shack

It’s funny that with the plethora of fresh seafood we ate, I chose this recipe as my travel inspiration. Don’t you love when something is unexpectedly good?  Isn’t it better than expecting something to be so delicious, and it’s disappointing?

Womp womp.

After a morning long run, we wanted a low key lunch place. Somewhere we could sit outside, split an app, and have a beer. However, being the day before the SeaWheeze half marathon, it made things rather difficult.

We walked by a place called Tap Shack, and it was hoppin’. Like people galore outside, and a line out the door. Fortunately, we snuck on into the bar and found a seat immediately. Originally, I had a cheesy burger in mind, but they weren’t serving that burger at our location. As a result, I did a total 180 with my menu decisions, and went with the veggie sandwich. While it sounded tasty, I wasn’t expecting too much out of it.

However, I was pleasantly surprised and delighted by the sandwich, and I left Tap Shack feeling inspired to create my own version.

I’m excited to share this ultimate veggie sandwich recipe with you today.

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

I did make a few changes – I traded the Portobello mushroom for eggplant, switched the bibb lettuce to spinach and omitted the cucumber.

Most importantly, I suggest using a hearty or thick bread. You need something sturdy to hold all of the thick vegetable goodness.

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

And, while we’re at it, let’s talk about nutrition, shall we?

This sandwich is chockfull of nutrients, fiber and antioxidants. You’re getting ample healthy fats through the avocado, which will help you absorb the Vitamins A, E, and K from the veggies.

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

While you’re getting sufficient protein from the goat cheese, as well as some from the bread, avocado and veggies, you can certainly buff up the protein content. You can add in bacon, tofu, tempeh, deli meat or even a fried egg, if you so dare.

You guys know my obsession with beets (here and here). Beets are high in antioxidants and nitrates, and can help reduce blood pressure. Furthermore, beets are high in betanin. Betanin is a phytonutrient associated with reducing inflammation and helping with detoxification. The sandwich is also full of B vitamins, potassium, Vitamin C.

[Tweet “Get the recipe for this ultimate #vegetarian sandwich #recipe, full of nutrients and antioxidants! #recideredux”]

Raise your hand if you like creamy goat cheese…

All hands raised? This sandwich would not be the same without it. It’s paramount for the creaminess.

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

And, the goat cheese imparts such a creaminess, the tomato gives a juicy tartness, the beets provide some natural sweetness, and the buttered bread holds it together and leaves you with a satisfying, savory taste. There are so many flavors in this sandwich but I feel like they go really well together.

If you want to make this vegan, omit the goat cheese and substitute with hummus or another vegan cheese, and substitute more olive oil for the butter.

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich10

[Tweet “Eggplants, avocado, goat cheese, beets and more in this epic #veggie sandwich!”]

Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

Lastly, the eggplant plays the role of the “meat” here. While it’s chewy and thick, it doesn’t take away from all of the other flavors. As a great Meatless Monday option, that can be customized for the whole family.

5 from 1 vote
Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich
Prep Time
7 mins
Cook Time
7 mins
Total Time
14 mins
A nutrient-packed sandwich that doesn't sacrifice any of the flavor! It can be made in under 15 minutes and boasts a nice balance of sweet and savory.
Course: sandwich
Servings: 1 sandwich
Author: Sarah @ Bucket List Tummy
  • ½ small eggplant roasted
  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • 2 slices of bread I used Sara Lee Artisan
  • 1 1/2 tbsp butter
  • ¼ cup sliced beets I used canned
  • 2 tbsp goat cheese
  • 2 tbsp sprouts
  • ½ avocado mashed
  • 1-2 slices tomato
  • 1/2 cup spinach
  • salt and pepper to taste
  1. Preheat broiler on low.
  2. Cut eggplant in ½ inch slices, brush both sides with a teaspoon of olive oil, and arrange in single layer on baking sheet (I added a pinch of salt also).
  3. Broil for 4 minutes, turn over, and broil for 4 more minutes.
  4. While the eggplant is broiling, coat bread with 1-2 tsp of butter and saute in frying pan over medium high heat. Cook for about 2 minutes, and do the same with the other side.
  5. Once bread is toasted to your liking, coat each slice of bread with mashed avocado and goat cheese (add salt and pepper as necessary). Layer bottom slice of toast with sprouts, beets, sliced tomato, spinach and broiled eggplant.
  6. Put sandwich back in the broiler on low for 2-3 more minutes. Combine top and bottom slices, forming your sandwich.


Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

Don’t forget to check out the other yummy Recipe Redux creations below!

[inlinkz_linkup id=651194 mode=1]

What makes a sandwich stand out to you?

Your go-to sandwich bread?

32 responses to “Creamy Eggplant Veggie Sandwich

  1. Give me all the goat cheese!! I just bought some from Trader Joe’s on Friday and it’s already gone. I’m not very good at preparing eggplant but I love it when I get it out. I need to try again I think!

  2. I love how vibrant the colors are in this sandwich! It definitely catches your eye! and goat cheese…mmmm…sign me up! Thanks for sharing!

  3. Welcome to the Redux family 🙂 I’m always look for fun vegetarian sandwiches- my little sis is vegetarian and since it’s back to school she needs some ideas so I’ll be sharing this with her (and making it myself!)

  4. This looks so good! I made a delicious veggie sandwich last night that hit the spot and I debated adding beets and eggplant but didn’t and now I’m wishing I would have. Guess I’ll have to make another one! Thank you for linking up with us for Meatless Monday!

  5. YUM. I don’t buy a lot of eggplant because the only thing I ever really see it used for is eggplant parm, but I can’t ever seem to make it as good as a restaurant. But this I could definitely do! I love that it’s not fried. And I LOVE me some goat cheese. I would probably add bacon on this just for the salt factor, but this absolutely sounds delicious. Add a cold beer or cider & it’s the perfect weekend lunch!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *