Struggle with getting dinner on the table? Grab our 5 easy family meal recipes!


Orange and Mango Smoothie

This Orange Mango Smoothie is the perfect cold, creamy and refreshing post workout smoothie. This smoothie made with yogurt tastes like like an orange creamsicle smoothie and will nourish your body and taste buds!

orange mango smoothie with cara cara oranges in wine glasses | Bucket List Tummy

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. You can read more here on our Disclaimer and Privacy Page.

Greek yogurt smoothies are great as pregnancy smoothies, post workout smoothies, and everything in between.

And this mango smoothie with yogurt is the newest addition to my favorite.

During both of my pregnancies, I enjoyed my fair share of citrus fruits, especially blood oranges and frozen mango, so I made this creamsicle protein shake blending the two.

Honestly, I always thought I wanted citrus more in the summer when it’s hot.

But, this orangesicle smoothie is too good to not enjoy year round.

An orange and mango smoothie is the best combination of two awesome, juicy fruits. 

Ingredients in Orange and Mango Smoothie

  • Cara Cara oranges (or any type of orange)
  • frozen mango
  • plain greek yogurt – You could also use vanilla flavored
  • milk
  • protein powder (I prefer vanilla for this recipe. Choose from any of these protein powders for runners!)
  • salt
  • vanilla extract
  • maple syrup (optional)

As I mentioned, this orange creamsicle shake came about because I became obsessed with Cara Cara oranges.

They taste like a blend of a sweet orange and a grapefruit and they make this creamsicle smoothie the best ever.

They also work great as roasted oranges – so much flavor!

And, because of their hydrating ability and antioxidant content, blended with carbs and protein, this mango smoothie with yogurt makes for a great post recovery workout smoothie.

Protein for runners is usually underemphasized, so this is an easy and convenient, high-protein option.

mango smoothie with greek yogurt and orange on top in clear glass

Mango is just a very refreshing addition to a smoothie.

I added it to this cantaloupe mango smoothie and was pleasantly surprised. It also makes a good substitution for frozen peaches in this banana peach smoothie.

The Best Post Run Smoothie

Let’s discuss why this mango greek yogurt smoothie is great for runners and athletes, and makes the cut for a great healthy snack for athletes.

The nutritional benefits and breakdown make it the best after workout smoothie.

  • ProteinWhey protein is important after a workout, and especially incorporating the amino acid, leucine. Leucine helps with muscle growth and decreasing muscle breakdown. Leucine is a brancehd chain amino acid, and BCAAs for runners may be helpful in some circumstances if adequate protein is challenging. Greek yogurt, milk and protein powder supply ample protein.
  • Vitamins A & C – These vitamins are antioxidant and is great for reducing inflammation in the body and enhancing immunity. Vitamin C also helps with iron absorption.
  • Polyphenols – These are anti-inflammatory compounds that help neutralize free radicals and inflammation in the body and can help enhance recovery. As discussed in the journal, Oxidative Medicine, polyphenols help mitigate oxidative stress.
  • Carbohydrates – Fruit and dairy offer some carbohydrates, which the body takes up as quick sugars to help improve recovery post-workout. Mangos and bananas are great running recovery foods!
  • Electrolytes Electrolytes for runners are also very important and help with hydration. This smoothie bursts sodium, potassium and some magnesium. The 1/8 tsp of salt adds 260 mg of sodium to help replenish that lost in sweat. Potassium is important to replenish, too, since it helps with muscle cramps and balancing heart contractions. 

With the hint of citrus and tropical fruits + the creamy dairy addition + the slight sweetness – this orange and mango smoothie is almost too good to be true. 

orange and mango smoothie in glasses with oranges on top

Of course, it will be super refreshing and hydrating for summer hydration and to refuel after a summer workout.

This after workout smoothie recipe also holds its own in the winter, though, when oranges are in season and you start to crave them more. 

How to Make an Orange Creamsicle Shake

To make this orange cream smoothie most taste like a creamsicle shake, don’t skimp on the citrus!

The care cara oranges work magically when combined with frozen mango and a creamy greek yogurt and vanilla protein powder.

Make sure you put the frozen mango and ice at the bottom of the blender or food processor. I use a ninja blender.

Then, add the greek yogurt, oranges, protein powder, salt and vanilla extract.

Add the milk or liquid last so you can control the creaminess. If you like a thicker smoothie, add less liquid. Or, add more for a thinner smoothie.

two clear glasses with orange smoothie and protein tub in background


While it’s easy to recognize our sweat in the summer, in winter dehydration can sneak under the radar with cooler temperatures because sweat evaporates quicker.

If you love the tropical flavors of strawberries and bananas, you may enjoy this strawberry and banana smoothie bowl recipe.

Can I make a dairy free smoothie?

Yes, you can make this smoothie dairy free. Use a plant-based milk and yogurt, or leave out the yogurt completely. Make sure there is no dairy in your protein powder.

Can I add banana?

Yes, you can add banana. It will add a natural sweetness.

Do I have to add ice?

No, you don’t have to add ice. You can add more frozen fruit, if you prefer, or leave it out entirely. The ice helps make it thicker and creamier, in my opinion, but it is not absolutely necessary.

More Smoothie Recipes

Refreshing Orange and Mango Smoothie
Yield: 2

Refreshing Orange and Mango Smoothie

Prep Time: 2 minutes
Cook Time: 2 minutes
Additional Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 9 minutes

This Orange and Mango Smoothie is the perfect cold and creamy post workout recovery smoothie. Enjoy the taste of the healthy creamsicle shake!



  1. Add ice and frozen mango to bottom of smoothie.
  2. Next, add yogurt, oranges, protein powder, salt and vanilla extract.
  3. Add milk last to control how liquidy you want it.
  4. Mix all ingredients into blender and blend to desired consistency. Final result should be creamy, like a milkshake


*If dairy free, coconut milk would be a great substitute

For a more liquid smoothie, add more milk. For a creamier shake, use less liquid.

Nutrition Information:



Serving Size:


Amount Per Serving: Calories: 436Total Fat: 8gSaturated Fat: 5gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 3gCholesterol: 33mgSodium: 391mgCarbohydrates: 67gFiber: 4gSugar: 25gProtein: 27g

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Make This?

Tag @BucketListTummy on social media and Rate the Recipe

Join The Conversation

More For You!

Share Your Thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like This Content?

Support Bucket List Tummy
  1. I love Cara Cara oranges and also love creamsicles so this smoothie sounds perfect- especially with all the protein packed in!

Skip to Recipe